From the Editor

From the Editor

Anil Tyagi
anil-tyagi-editor-gfiles

Anil Tyagi – Editor Gfiles

THREE issues plague the Indian Police today: politicisation, lack of professionalism and alienation from large sections of the society. The current thinking on police reforms is that if the first two concerns are addressed, the third will automatically be dealt with.

Unfortunately, experiences from several mature and developed democracies prove that this is not necessarily so. De-politicisation and professionalism make the police efficient, but not moral. They make the force adept at crime-solving, but not problem-solving for the society. In fact, it is not rocket science to believe that even if the Indian Police gets rid of the political influences, and has access to modern technology and huge funds, it will continue to be as brutal as it is today, and continue to misuse and abuse its powers against the weaker sections.

In the 1950s, America believed that its police was among the best in the world. It was independent of politics, autonomous, and far ahead in terms of adoption of global best practices. The 1960s shattered this myth. During the decade, the crime rate per 100,000 people doubled; the increase in the rate of violent crimes, like robberies, was higher. More important, police action against African-Americans and students’ movements in the 1960s showed its dark and ugly sides. The Kerner Commission concluded that “police conduct included brutality, harassment, and abuse of power”. Research found that the American police followed racial discrimination in employment, arrests, and the use of deadly force.

Doesn’t this remind us of the state of Indian Police in the 21st century, with its regular violent and inhuman acts against Indian citizens during riots, protests, and even in everyday lives? Shockingly, what had been deemed good for the US Police in the decades preceding the 1960s turned out to be worse for it. De-politicisation left the force unprotected from criticism by the executive, media, and judiciary. Technology, like fast-moving vehicles for mobile patrolling and high-tech weapons, “eliminated routine contact” with the people, and “exacerbated police-community problems”. There was complete disconnect between the police and society.

Thus was born the idea and philosophy of community policing. This maintained that the role of the police wasn’t reactive and crime-control, but a proactive one that solves the crucial, critical, and inherent issues that trouble various communities. According to experts, this entailed three new responsibilities: continuous engagement and interaction with the people; ability to solve the daily problems of the community; and adaptation of the police organisation to fulfil these duties. Clearly, the police had to be community-oriented. It had to understand the needs of the society, and then act in a manner to resolve them amicably and peacefully. In the past five decades, the American Police inculcated these new dimensions to emerge as a new sensitised force.

India needs a similar approach. The current wave of reforms, as expressed by the Supreme Court and pushed through by the police itself, seems to be a case of protecting the force’s self interests. By focusing on de-politicisation and professionalism, they seem to be intent on how to make the police independent. It is a laudable objective, but it will not be enough. In fact, it may lead to worse problems in the near future. What we need is a police that serves the people and citizens in a fair and transparent manner. What is required is a new moral manifesto, a set of new values that will make the Indian Police work in the interests of the people. What we need today is a People’s Police, a force that is of the people, by the people, and more importantly, only for the people.

Anil Tyagi
editor@gfilesindia.com 

Vol. 12 | ISSUE 6 | SEPT 2018
Click to comment

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply

To Top
Latest Articles
close slider

Lastest Articles

 
From the Editor : Anil Tyagi
 
Eyes Wide Shut : A unique initiative
 
Police Reforms : Crime and Politics
 
Police Reforms : Fear remains the key
 
Police Reforms : Sensitising the police
 
Governance : Railways – Sarkar or Vyapar ?
 
Governance : AFSPA – A law that needs to go
 
Governance : A case of an FIR and an award
 
Governance : Development Agenda for New India 2022
 
Governance : Time to cash in
 
Governance : Too much noise
 
Corruption : FROM RAJ TO RAFALE – 1 : Clive of Corruption
 
Bric a brac : Amit Shah takes centrestage
 
Bric a brac : Arrogant ministers and the media
 
Bric a brac : AICC faces space constraint
 
Bric a brac : Now, Made in Gujarat
 
By the way : Rockstar Amitabh
 
By the way : J&K Police needs a DG
 
By the way : Roaring Khandelwal
 
By the way : Super Chief Minister!